16 Comments

The link in footnote 14 is broken.

Expand full comment

Fascinating as always. Thank you. A question however. In the first illustration, glass lenses are shown. Wouldn't plain glass windows have let in the same amount of heat or energy in such a setup?

Expand full comment

Great reading!

Only small technical remarks - most of described machines work by shrinking and expansion of gas (air), not by condensation. Even Savery's machine works by mixed shrinking of air and condensation.

And Huygens is Christiaan, not Constantijn.

Expand full comment

Today original thinkers can be reached by the veneer of advanced education.

The concept of perpetual motive can be closely approached using air pressure provided by a VAWT.

The air over hydraulic configuration can drive any machine with incredible force.

Combining this method with a hydraulic hub and one has motive power.

MORE to the story.....

Expand full comment
Jul 21, 2022·edited Jul 21, 2022

Why haven't you mentioned the Worcester's water-commanding engine?

1663 description of "fire-water work" in Worcester's Century of Inventions:

“ An admirable and most forcible way to drive up water by fire; not by drawing or sucking it upwards, for that must be as the philosopher colleth it intra sphaeram activitatis, which is but at such a distance. But this way hath no bounder, if the vessel be strong enough ; for I have taken a piece of a whole cannon, whereof the end was burst, and filled it three quarters full of water, stopping and screwing up the broken end, as also the touchhole, and making a constant fire under it; within twenty-four hours it burst, and made a great crack : so that, having a way to make my vessels, so that they are strengthened by the force within them, and the one to fill after the other, I have seen the water run like a constant fountain-stream, forty feet high : one vessel of water, rarefied by fire, driveth up forty of cold water, and a man that tends the work, is but to turn two cocks, that one vessel of water being consumed, another begins to force and refill with cold water, and so successively, the fire being tended and kept constant, which the self-same person may likewise abundantly perform in the interim between the necessity ot turning the said cocks.”

Expand full comment